121 & 125 John Gay Road, South Bristol, ME 04568

$2,650,000
Property Type: Residential Bedrooms: 5 Baths: 4 Square Footage: 3,510 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 69,696 Status: Closed
Current Price: $2,650,000 List Date: 4/30/2025 Last Modified: 6/17/2025

Overview

Description

Enjoy quintessential coastal living in this sought after neighborhood of Rutherford Island, known for its shingled summer homes overlooking John's Island, John's Bay and the Gulf of Maine, where life on the water is right at your finger tips. A private location on a dead-end road, this 1.6 acre parcel offers 450 +/- feet of shorefront with its tidal pools, a deep-water dock and private cove with a beach. A contemporary style five bedroom Main House features an open living space with cathedral ceiling, large windows and massive stone fireplace. A separate Guest House offers two additional bedrooms and 2 full baths; both properties feature expansive decks offering panoramic views of John's Bay. Plenty of room to invite your family and friends to enjoy a classic coastal Maine experience. From your own deep water dock enjoy many boating conveniences. Explore nearby Witch Island by kayak, a wildlife sanctuary and preserve maintained by Coastal Rivers. A great opportunity to own your own wat ...

Listing Details MLS# 1620855

Property Sub-Type

Property Sub-Type
Single Family Residence

Location Information

Street #
121 & 125
Street Name
John Gay
Street Type
Road
County
Lincoln
Town
South Bristol
State/Province
ME
Zip Code
04568
Leased Land
No
Book
6150
Page
1-27
Map
18
Lot
01-F
Zoning
Shoreland
Zoning Overlay
Unknown
Neighborhood Association
Fire Road 12
Association
Yes
Association Fee
1250
Fee Frequency Paid
Annually
Full Tax Amount $
8429
Tax Year
2024
Tree Growth Y/N
No

Contract Information

Original List Price
2995000

Property Information

Surveyed
Yes
Seasonal
No
# Rooms
9
# Bedrooms
5
# Fireplaces
Yes
Total Full Baths
2
Total Half Baths
2
Total Baths
4
Color
grey
Year Built
1985
SqFt Finished Above Grade
3510
SqFt Finished Total
3510
SqFt Source
Seller
Garage
Yes
Garage Spaces
2
Lot Size Acres +/-
1.6
Source of Acreage
Public Records
SqFt Finished Below Grade
0

Status Change Info

Pending Date
2025-05-06
Closed Date
2025-06-17
Closed Price
2650000

Water Info

Water Frontage
Yes
Waterfront Amount
450
Water Frontage Owned
450
Water View
Yes
Water Body Name
John's Bay
Island
No
Water Frontage Shared
0

More Information

Vehicle Storage

Attached
Yes
2 Car
Yes
Auto Door Opener
Yes
Direct Entry to Living
Yes

Sold Info

Appraiser Email Address
tiffany.monroe@yahoo.com

Site

Rolling/Sloping
Yes
Wooded
Yes

Location

Near Golf Course
Yes
Rural
Yes

Roads

Association
Yes
Dead End
Yes
Private Road
Yes

Source of Water Frontage

Survey
Yes

Water Body Type

Bay
Yes
Ocean
Yes
River
Yes

Recreational Water

Dock
Yes
Oceanfront
Yes
Waterfront Deep
Yes

Construction

Wood Frame
Yes

Basement

Unfinished
Yes
Walk-Out Access
Yes

Foundation Materials

Poured Concrete
Yes

Exterior

Shingle Siding
Yes
Wood Siding
Yes

Roof

Shingle
Yes

Heat System

Radiator
Yes

Appliances Included

Cooktop
Yes
Dishwasher
Yes
Refrigerator
Yes
Wall Oven
Yes

Heat Fuel

Electric
Yes
Wood
Yes

Cooling

None
Yes

Floors

Carpet
Yes
Tile
Yes
Wood
Yes

Kitchen Countertop

Formica
Yes
Granite
Yes

Parking

1 - 4 Spaces
Yes
5 - 10 Spaces
Yes

Style

Shingle
Yes

Electric

Circuit Breakers
Yes

Bedroom 1

Bedroom 1
Yes
Bedroom 1 Level
Second

Gas

Bottled
Yes

Sewer

Private Sewer
Yes
Septic Design Available
Yes
Septic Tank
Yes

Bedroom 2

Bedroom 2
Yes
Bedroom 2 Level
Second

Water

Private
Yes
Well
Yes

Bedroom Amenities 2

Closet
Yes

Bedroom 3

Bedroom 3
Yes
Bedroom 3 Level
Second

Bedroom Amenities 3

Closet
Yes

Bedroom 4

Bedroom 4
Yes
Bedroom 4 Level
Second

Bedroom Amenities 4

Above Garage
Yes
Closet
Yes

Driveway

Gravel
Yes

Basement Entry

Interior
Yes

Water Heater

Oil
Yes

Amenities

Laundry - 1st Floor
Yes
Pantry
Yes
Primary Bedroom w/Bath
Yes
Shower
Yes
Walk-in Closets
Yes

Dining Room

Dining Room
Yes
Dining Room Level
First

Dining Room Amenities

Built-Ins
Yes
Informal
Yes

Kitchen

Kitchen
Yes
Kitchen Level
First

Kitchen Amenities

Eat-in Kitchen
Yes
Island
Yes

Laundry Room

Laundry
Yes
Laundry Room Level
First

Laundry Room Amenities

Utility Sink
Yes

Living Room

Living Room
Yes
Living Room Level
First

Living Room Amenities

Built-Ins
Yes
Cathedral Ceiling
Yes
Wood Burning Fireplace
Yes

Primary Bedroom

Primary Bedroom
Yes
Primary Bedroom Level
Second

Primary Bedroom Amenities

Closet
Yes
Full Bath
Yes

Room Features

Above Garage
Yes
Built-Ins
Yes
Cathedral Ceiling(s)
Yes
Closet
Yes
Eat-in Kitchen
Yes
Full Bath
Yes
Informal
Yes
Kitchen Island
Yes
Utility Sink
Yes
Wood Burning Fireplace
Yes

Property Features

Site: Rolling/Sloping; Wooded Location: Near Golf Course; Rural Roads: Association; Dead End; Private Road Source of Water Frontage: Survey Water Body Type: Bay; Ocean; River Recreational Water: Dock; Oceanfront; Waterfront Deep Appliances Included: Cooktop; Dishwasher; Refrigerator; Wall Oven Kitchen Countertop: Formica; Granite Style: Shingle Construction: Wood Frame Basement: Unfinished; Walk-Out Access Basement Entry: Interior Foundation Materials: Poured Concrete Roof: Shingle Exterior: Shingle Siding; Wood Siding Heat System: Radiator Heat Fuel: Wood Water Heater: Oil Cooling: None Floors: Carpet; Tile; Wood Amenities: Laundry - 1st Floor; Pantry; Primary Bedroom w/Bath; Shower; Walk-in Closets Driveway: Gravel Parking: 1 - 4 Spaces; 5 - 10 Spaces Vehicle Storage: 2 Car; Auto Door Opener; Direct Entry to Living Electric: Circuit Breakers Gas: Bottled Sewer: Private Sewer; Septic Design Available; Septic Tank Water: Private; Well

Room Information

Room Name Level
Primary Bedroom Second
Bedroom 1 Second
Bedroom 2 Second
Bedroom 3 Second
Bedroom 4 Second
Dining Room First
Kitchen First
Laundry First
Living Room First
IDX
Listing Office: Legacy Properties Sotheby's International Realty
Selling Office: Legacy Properties Sotheby's International Realty
Last Updated: June - 17 - 2025
Listing data is derived in whole or in part from the Maine IDX and is for consumers' personal, noncommercial use only. Dimensions are approximate and not guaranteed. All data should be independently verified. Copyright ©2026 Maine Real Estate Information System, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Equal Housing Opportunity.