1024 Stillwater Avenue, Old Town, ME 04468

$348,000
Property Type: Multi-Family Baths: 3 Square Footage: 5,510 Lot Size (sq. ft.): 22,216 Status: Active
Current Price: $348,000 List Date: 9/05/2025 Last Modified: 3/05/2026

Overview

Description

Welcome to 1024 Stillwater Avenue, a grand 5,500 sq. ft. farmhouse dating back to 1892, set just a short stroll from the Stillwater River Reservoir. Steeped in history and cherished by the same family for 42 years, this property also holds the legacy of housing the award-winning Stillwater Montessori School, a beloved community institution since 1983. Historic character is preserved throughout, from original cabinetry and fine woodwork to gleaming birds-eye maple and oak floors, all crowned by a magnificent front entry with paned windows leading into a grand hall and staircase with a carved newel post. Perfectly situated at the corner of Stillwater and College Avenue, the property is minutes from the University of Maine, I-95, shopping, recreation, and trails. The half-acre lot offers two points of access, with a driveway connecting Stillwater Avenue to Old Mill Road and a small garage ideal for storage or parking. A rare grandfathered two-unit within an R1 zone, the home offers tremendous flexibility—as a single-family residence, a two-family, or, with town approval, a business such as a school, church, or public facility. Inside are 18 rooms, three bathrooms, and a converted barn with two levels of four-season space, plus a large unfinished attic brimming with potential. Modern updates on the first floor include hard-wired smoke detectors, exit signs, and emergency lighting. while practical exterior features include parking for 12-14 cars and a fenced-in yard. With solid bones, timeless beauty, and limitless possibilities, this remarkable property is ready for its next vision. Open House Sunday September 7th, 11:00-2:00

Listing Details MLS# 1636628

Location Information

Street #
1024
Street Name
Stillwater
Street Type
Avenue
County
Penobscot
Town
Old Town
State/Province
ME
Zip Code
04468
Zip +4
5112
Leased Land
No
Book
B3359
Page
263
Map
017
Block
065
Lot
000
Zoning
Low Density R1
Zoning Overlay
No
Association
No
Full Tax Amount $
5374
Tax Year
2024
Tree Growth Y/N
No

Contract Information

Original List Price
399000

Property Information

Surveyed
Unknown
Seasonal
No
Owner Occupied
Yes
Deed/Conveyance Type Offered
Warranty
Deed
All
Deed Restrictions
Yes
Bank Owned REO
No
2 Detached Houses on 1 Lot
No
Number of Units
2
Total Baths
3
Total Full Baths
2
Total Half Baths
Yes
Color
White
Year Built
1892
SqFt Finished Above Grade
5510
SqFt Finished Total
5510
SqFt Source
Appraiser
Furniture
Unfurnished
Garage
Yes
Garage Spaces
Yes
Lot Size Acres +/-
0.51
Source of Acreage
Public Records
Road Frontage
Yes
Road Frontage +/-
231
Source of Road Frontage
Public Records
SqFt Finished Below Grade
0

Water Info

Water Frontage
No
Water View
No

Building Info

# Stories
3
# Heating Units
4
# Water Heaters
Yes

Units

# of 2 BD Units
Yes
# of 3 BD Units
Yes

More Information

Fixtures Exclusions

Fixtures Exclusions
Stained Glass

Unit 1

Lease
No
Level
First
Security Deposit
No
# Full Baths
Yes
# of Half Baths
Yes
# of Rooms
6
# of Bedrooms
2
Dedicated Electric Meter
Yes
Dedicated Gas Meter
No
Dedicated Water Heater
No
Electric
Yes
Heat
Yes
Range
No
Refrigerator
No
Sewer
Yes
Water
Yes
Monthly Rent
0

Unit 2

Lease
No
Level
Second
Security Deposit
No
# Full Baths
Yes
# of Rooms
11
# of Bedrooms
3
Dedicated Electric Meter
Yes
Dedicated Gas Meter
No
Dedicated Water Heater
No
Electric
Yes
Heat
Yes
Range
Yes
Refrigerator
Yes
Sewer
Yes
Water
Yes
Monthly Rent
0

Levels

Multi-Level
Yes

Site

Agricultural
Yes
Corner Lot
Yes
Farm
Yes
Level
Yes
Sidewalks
Yes

Location

Business District
Yes
Intown
Yes
Near Town
Yes
Near Turnpike/Interstate
Yes

Roads

Paved
Yes
Public
Yes

Transportation

Major Road Access
Yes
Public Transport Access
Yes

Style

Colonial
Yes
Farmhouse
Yes
New Englander
Yes
Victorian
Yes

Construction

Wood Frame
Yes

Other Structures

Outbuilding
Yes

Basement

Crawl Space
Yes
Dirt Floor
Yes
Full
Yes
Unfinished
Yes

Foundation Materials

Brick/Mortar
Yes
Stone
Yes

Exterior

Vinyl Siding
Yes
Wood Siding
Yes

Roof

Shingle
Yes
Tar/Gravel
Yes

Heat System

Direct Vent Heater
Yes
Hot Water
Yes
Radiator
Yes

Heat Fuel

Gas Bottled
Yes
Oil
Yes
Propane
Yes

Income & Expenses

Gross Income
0
Operating Expenses
6500

Cooling

None
Yes

Floors

Hardwood
Yes
Vinyl
Yes
Wood
Yes

Parking

11 - 20 Spaces
Yes
On Site
Yes

Electric

Circuit Breakers
Yes

Gas

Bottled
Yes

Sewer

Public Sewer
Yes

Water

Public
Yes

Driveway

Gravel
Yes

Basement Entry

Interior
Yes

Water Heater

Electric
Yes

Window Features

Storm Window(s)
Yes

Amenities

1st Floor Bedroom
Yes
Attic
Yes
Bathtub
Yes
Fence
Yes
One-Floor Living
Yes
Pantry
Yes
Shower
Yes
Storage
Yes

Patio and Porch Features

Porch
Yes

Vehicle Storage

1 Car
Yes
Detached
Yes

Property Features

Site: Agricultural; Corner Lot; Farm; Level; Sidewalks Location: Business District; Intown; Near Town; Near Turnpike/Interstate Roads: Paved; Public Transportation: Major Road Access; Public Transport Access Style: Colonial; Farmhouse; New Englander; Victorian Levels: Multi-Level Construction: Wood Frame Other Structures: Outbuilding Basement: Crawl Space; Dirt Floor; Full; Unfinished Basement Entry: Interior Foundation Materials: Brick/Mortar; Stone Exterior: Vinyl Siding; Wood Siding Roof: Shingle; Tar/Gravel Heat System: Direct Vent Heater; Hot Water; Radiator Heat Fuel: Gas Bottled; Oil; Propane Water Heater: Electric Cooling: None Floors: Hardwood; Vinyl; Wood Window Features: Storm Window(s) Amenities: 1st Floor Bedroom; Attic; Bathtub; Fence; One-Floor Living; Pantry; Shower; Storage Patio and Porch Features: Porch Driveway: Gravel Parking: 11 - 20 Spaces; On Site Vehicle Storage: 1 Car; Detached Electric: Circuit Breakers Gas: Bottled Sewer: Public Sewer Water: Public

Documents

Listing Office: Townsend Real Estate
IDX
Last Updated: March - 05 - 2026
Listing data is derived in whole or in part from the Maine IDX and is for consumers' personal, noncommercial use only. Dimensions are approximate and not guaranteed. All data should be independently verified. Copyright ©2022 Maine Real Estate Information System, Inc. All Rights Reserved. Equal Housing Opportunity.
Search powered by FBS Products